The letters of each answer can be found hidden in the illustration; fill in the blanks with the object the letters comprise:
| Academics Scavenger Hunt — HONEY | -> | brancH |
| Agatha's Books — RAVEN | -> | clOak |
| Notes on a 7-Course Meal — CUTLERY | -> | Umbrella |
| Faux Amigos — MOONLIGHT | -> | caStle |
| Shifty — SENSE | -> | goosE |
The indicated letters spell HOUSE, fitting the first part of the enumeration "***** OF ???????". Looking at the picture, the house is made of the letters of MIRRORS, implying the final answer HOUSE OF MIRRORS.